November 17, 2026
UK CIS contractors switching to Xero or QuickBooks: mid-month vs the 6th, what carries across, and what each product files
The short answer: if you are a CIS contractor moving to Xero or QuickBooks Online, cut over on the 6th of a month, the first day of a CIS tax month. File the last return for the old tax month from your old software, carry each subcontractor’s verification number and deduction rate across by hand, and keep the old system’s CIS records for at least three years after the tax year ends. Neither product imports CIS return history, and QuickBooks Online cannot file a return for a period before you switched CIS on.
The rules below come from HMRC’s guide “What you must do as a Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) contractor” on GOV.UK, Intuit’s UK help article “Setting up CIS payments and returns in QuickBooks” (published 10 November 2026) and Xero’s UK CIS product page, all read on 17 November 2026.
The CIS calendar your cutover has to respect
CIS runs on tax months from the 6th of one month to the 5th of the next, not on calendar months or VAT quarters. For each tax month a contractor must:
- give each subcontractor a payment and deduction statement within 14 days of the end of the tax month;
- file the monthly return (CIS300) by the 19th;
- pay the deductions to HMRC by the 22nd, or the 19th if paying by post.
A month with no payments still needs a nil return, unless you have told HMRC the scheme is inactive, which covers up to six months. Late returns cost £100 at one day late and £200 at two months; at six and twelve months HMRC charges the greater of £300 or 5% of the deductions on the return, and later still up to £3,000 or 100% of the deductions. A return split badly across two systems is the easiest way to end up late.
Mid-month vs the 6th: why the date matters
| Cut over on the 6th | Cut over mid tax month | |
|---|---|---|
| Last return from old software | Complete tax month, filed as normal | Payments for one tax month sit in two systems |
| Who files that month’s CIS300 | Old software | One return has to be assembled from two ledgers |
| Subcontractor statements | One per subcontractor from each system, for different months | Risk of two partial statements for the same month |
| First return from new software | The first full tax month after cutover | Only clean from the following month |
A worked timeline: switch on 6 December 2026. The old software files the 6 November to 5 December return by 19 December and you pay by 22 December. Xero or QuickBooks records every payment from 6 December, and its first return, for 6 December to 5 January, is due by 19 January 2027.
Xero vs QuickBooks Online for a CIS contractor
| Xero (UK) | QuickBooks Online (UK) | |
|---|---|---|
| Calculate deductions and run CIS reports | Starter, Standard and Premium plans | Switched on under Settings > Account and settings > Advanced > CIS |
| Verify subcontractors with HMRC | With the CIS contractor add-on | Built in: Verify on the supplier, signing in with Government Gateway; QuickBooks fetches the verification number and rate |
| File the CIS300 to HMRC | With the CIS contractor add-on; without it you export the return | Accounting > CIS > Prepare return > Submit to HMRC |
| Subcontractor statements | Bulk email with the add-on | Email in batches of up to 50 |
| Earlier periods | Not described on the page we read | Cannot be created or filed in QuickBooks; submit directly to HMRC |
| Points to know | Add-on is a separate subscription | CIS cannot be turned off once enabled; CIS figures are on a cash basis; tracking starts from the month you enable it |
Intuit adds that a filed return can take up to 72 hours to show its status, that rejections are usually a wrong Government Gateway login, a mismatched UTR or PAYE reference, or special characters such as & in a name, and that to edit a filed period you unfile returns one at a time, most recent first. It also tells you to use the dedicated CIS accounts QuickBooks creates rather than any you built by hand before. If you are also a subcontractor, both products let you record deductions suffered; in QuickBooks you tick “I am a CIS subcontractor” and choose your rate.
What to carry across, and what to leave
- Subcontractor records. For each subcontractor: name exactly as registered with HMRC, UTR, National Insurance number (sole traders) or company registration number (companies), verification number and rate (0% gross payment, 20% registered, 30% unregistered). QuickBooks has a field for a verification number you already hold.
- Re-verify only where the rules say so. HMRC requires you to verify a new subcontractor before paying them, and to re-verify one you have not included on a CIS return in the current or last two tax years. Everyone else keeps their existing verification. Temporary NI numbers starting “TN” cannot be verified.
- Open supplier invoices. Bring unpaid subcontractor invoices across individually, not as one balance, so the labour and materials split is there when you pay. CIS deductions are taken from the gross payment excluding VAT and the cost of materials, consumable stores, fuel (other than for travel), plant hire and manufactured materials the subcontractor bought.
- History stays behind, on file. Export the old system’s CIS returns, statements and payment records. HMRC requires records for at least three years after the end of the tax year they relate to, with a penalty of up to £3,000 if you cannot produce them.
A short example with illustrative figures: a registered subcontractor invoices £1,000 of labour and £300 of materials they bought, plus VAT. The deduction is 20% of £1,000, so £200 goes to HMRC on your return. VAT is handled separately and may fall under the domestic reverse charge; our post on UK VAT schemes when you switch software covers the VAT side of the cutover.
If payroll is moving at the same time, the dates rarely line up: see switching UK payroll software mid-year vs at 6 April.
FAQ
Can I import past CIS returns into Xero or QuickBooks Online?
Neither vendor page we read describes importing CIS return history, and Intuit says returns for previous periods cannot be created or filed in QuickBooks; they go directly to HMRC. Keep the old returns as exported files.
Do I have to re-verify my subcontractors when I change software?
No, not because of the software change. HMRC only requires re-verification if the subcontractor has not been on one of your CIS returns in the current or last two tax years. Carry the existing verification numbers across.
When is the best day to switch CIS software?
The 6th of the month, the start of a CIS tax month. The old software then files the last complete month and the new one starts clean.
Related service: UK conversions to Xero and QuickBooks, with VAT and CIS history handled