Established MMXXVRemote-first · Serving the US & CanadaConversions both directions
care@ezconvertbooks.com

November 9, 2026

Switching payroll software mid-year in Canada: YTD, CPP/EI maximums and ROEs

The short answer: changing payroll software or payroll provider part-way through the year doesn’t change the employer. The CPP and EI yearly maximums keep counting from what you’ve already deducted, the year’s T4s still have to cover the whole year, and any Record of Employment (ROE) you issue later needs up to 53 weeks of pay-period history, including the weeks that sat in the old system. Carry the year-to-date figures across to the cent, keep the pay-period history, and agree in writing which system files the T4s.

Rules below are from the CRA’s Employers’ Guide – Payroll Deductions and Remittances (T4001) and Service Canada’s ROE guide and ROE Web requirements, as at November 2026. Québec employers also report to Revenu Québec (QPP, QPIP and the RL-1), where the same year-to-date logic applies; check those figures with Revenu Québec’s own guidance.

Why a mid-year switch is harder than a 1 January switch

CPP contributions and EI premiums are annual. The CRA tells employers to stop deducting CPP once an employee reaches the year’s maximum pensionable earnings or maximum contribution, and to deduct EI only up to the yearly maximum of insurable earnings. Both counters reset on 1 January.

Switch on 1 January and starting at zero is correct. Switch in August and some employees will already be part-way to the maximum, or past it. If the new software doesn’t know that, it starts deducting from zero again.

What has to carry across, per employee

  • Employment income and income tax deducted year to date
  • CPP pensionable earnings and CPP contributions (and second additional CPP, CPP2, where it applies)
  • EI insurable earnings and EI premiums
  • Insurable hours and insurable earnings by pay period (for ROEs; see below)
  • Taxable benefits and anything else that lands in a T4 box

Reconcile the totals before the first live pay run: the sum of each opening YTD field across all employees should equal the old system’s year-to-date payroll register and the remittances already made to the CRA.

Trap 1: CPP and EI start again from zero

An employee who hit the CPP maximum in September gets CPP deducted again from October because the new system thinks nothing has been paid.

The CRA’s fix for an over-deduction is to reimburse the employee, adjust your payroll records, and use the credit that creates on your payroll account (employee and employer share) to reduce a later remittance in the same calendar year. If you can’t reimburse, the over-deducted amount goes on the T4 and you can apply for a refund with Form PD24, no later than four years after the end of that year.

The opposite mistake is worse. If an opening balance is too high, the new system stops deducting too early. When CPP is under-deducted, the CRA holds you responsible for both the employer and employee share. You can recover the employee’s portion from later pays, but not more per pay than you should have deducted, and not for amounts outstanding for more than 12 months.

Trap 2: the ROE needs history from the old system

Service Canada says it is not a requirement to issue ROEs just because you change payroll service providers. If the new provider can’t issue ROEs for the period the previous one covered, the previous provider can issue them up to the date the new one takes over.

The catch comes later. When an employee has an interruption of earnings, the electronic ROE asks for the equivalent of 53 weeks of pay-period data in Block 15C. By pay frequency, that means:

  • Weekly: the last 53 pay periods
  • Biweekly: the last 27
  • Semi-monthly: the last 25
  • Monthly: the last 13
  • 13 pay periods a year: the last 14

Say you move to new software in January and lay someone off in April. Their ROE still needs the pay periods from the previous spring onwards, most of which were run in the old system. If the new system only holds YTD totals, someone has to rebuild that history by hand. For electronic ROEs on weekly, biweekly or semi-monthly payrolls, that work has to fit inside the five calendar days after the end of the pay period in which the interruption happened.

So even a clean 1 January switch should bring across at least 53 weeks of insurable earnings and hours by pay period, not just totals.

Trap 3: two systems, one T4 return

The T4 return is filed by payroll program account, and the slips have to reconcile to what was deducted and remitted under that account for the year. If the old provider and the new software both produce T4s for the same employees, you’ll get duplicate or partial slips and a summary that doesn’t match your remittances.

The cleanest arrangement is usually for the new system to file the whole year from the imported YTD figures. Whichever way you go, get it in writing from both providers before December. Keep the old system’s registers and reports too: the CRA expects payroll records to be kept for at least six years after the year they relate to. See keeping six years of records after switching software.

A changeover sequence that works

  1. Pick the switch date. If you can wait until 1 January, the CPP and EI problem disappears. Only the ROE history needs to come across.
  2. Run the last pay in the old system and make the remittance for it before anything else changes.
  3. Export the YTD register and the pay-period history (at least 53 weeks of insurable earnings and hours per employee).
  4. Load opening balances and tie every YTD field back to the old register and to the CRA remittances.
  5. Run a parallel or test pay and check CPP and EI on anyone near or past the maximum.
  6. Confirm in writing who issues any ROEs for the old period and who files the year’s T4s.

Changing payroll mid-year in another country? The UK version of this question is covered in switching payroll software mid-year vs 6 April, the Australian one in changing payroll software mid-year under STP, and New Zealand’s, where holiday pay is the trap, in switching payroll software mid-year in New Zealand.

FAQ

Do CPP and EI deductions restart when I change payroll software?

No. Changing software or payroll provider does not create a new employer. The yearly CPP and EI maximums keep counting from what has already been deducted this calendar year, so the new system needs each employee's year-to-date pensionable and insurable earnings and contributions. They reset on 1 January, not on the day you switch.

Do I have to issue ROEs when I change payroll service provider?

Service Canada says it is not a requirement to issue ROEs when you change payroll service providers. If the new provider can't issue ROEs covering the period handled by the previous one, the previous provider can issue them up to the date the new provider takes over.

What if the new system over-deducted CPP after the switch?

The CRA's guidance is to reimburse the employee, adjust your payroll records, and use the resulting credit on your payroll account to reduce a later remittance in the same calendar year. If you can't reimburse, the over-deduction is reported on the T4 and you can apply for a refund with Form PD24 within four years.

Related service: Accounting software conversions in Canada

Thinking about a conversion?

Send us your details for a free, fixed-price quote within one business day.